Custom Cakes for Every Occasion
Looking for a cake that’s as unique as your celebration? Our skilled cake decorators craft beautiful, custom cakes tailored to your event, your taste, and your style. Whether you’re marking a milestone or simply making someone feel special, we’ll help you create the perfect centerpiece.
Celebrate With a Custom Cake
We bake for all of life’s big (and small) celebrations. Some of our most popular custom cake requests include:
- Birthdays
- Weddings
- Anniversaries
- Baby Showers
We also make custom cakes for retirements, graduations, gender reveals, bridal showers, religious occasions, and more.
Cake Styles and Formats
Choose the right cake format to match your event:
- Sheet Cakes – Ideal for casual gatherings and larger guest lists
- Layer Cakes – Classic and versatile
- Tiered Cakes – Formal and impressive for big occasions
- Cupcake Platters – Perfect for easy sharing
Looking for something different? We also offer pull-apart cupcake cakes and other creative formats. See our FAQs for more.
Creative Designs and Themes
Our cake decorators specialize in themed, personalized cakes that reflect your vision and occasion. From elegant simplicity to imaginative themes, our cake decorators specialize in transforming ideas into edible art. Want a cake shaped like a favorite hobby, decorated with a cartoon character, or designed to match a party theme? If you can think it, we can bake it.
No two cakes are the same – and that’s exactly how we like it.
Flavor, Filling, and Icing Options
Every cake starts with flavor, and you can customize yours from top to bottom. Choose from popular options or request something unique.
Want something else? We offer many more combinations. See our FAQs for the full list.
Popular Cake Flavors:
- Classic Vanilla
- Rich Chocolate
- Velvety Red Velvet
- Marbled Swirl
- Spiced Carrot
Filling Options:
- Chocolate Mousse
- Raspberry Mousse
- Vanilla custard
- and more
Icing and Finishing Touches:
- Buttercream
- Whipped Cream
- Fondant
- Ganache
Planning and Ordering
Each cake is made to order with care and creativity. For most cakes, we require a minimum of 24 hours’ notice. Larger or more intricate cakes may need additional lead time.
Need delivery? We’ve got you covered. Our team will help you plan timing and logistics during the ordering process.
You’ll find our custom cakes available through all Adams stores, as part of our full-service Bakery Department.
Include a Custom Cake With Your Catering Order
If you’re planning a larger event with food service, don’t forget dessert. Custom cakes can be added to any Adams Catering Order, making event planning even easier.
Ready to Create Your Cake?
We’re here to make your cake vision a reality. Whether you have a clear design in mind or need help choosing the right style, our team is happy to guide you through the process.
Visit your nearest Adams Fairacre Farms location to get started or view our Online Custom Cake options.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I order a custom cake?
You can place a custom cake order by visiting the Bakery Department of any of our Adams stores in Poughkeepsie, Kingston, Newburgh, Wappinger, or Middletown. Our team will walk you through your options for style, flavor, and design.
How much notice is needed for a custom cake?
We typically need at least 24 hours for basic custom cakes. More elaborate cakes may require additional lead time.
Are your cakes available for delivery?
Yes, we offer cake delivery. Ask a bakery team member for more information when placing your order.
Can I include a custom cake as part of a catering order?
Yes, custom cakes can be added to Catering Orders. Let us know the event details and we’ll coordinate your dessert with the rest of your menu.
What kinds of custom cakes do you make?
We make custom cakes for all occasions—birthdays, weddings, baby showers, graduations, retirements, and more. We offer sheet cakes, layer cakes, tiered cakes, cupcake platters, and pull-apart cupcake cakes. We also create cakes for gender reveals, bridal showers, baptisms, communions, and any event worth celebrating.
Can I customize the flavor and filling of my cake?
Yes! Choose from a wide selection of cake flavors, fillings, and icings. You can also request something special. Our bakers are happy to accommodate custom flavor ideas when possible.
Popular filling options include:
- White chocolate mousse
- French pastry cream
- Chocolate custard
- Strawberry, cherry, lemon, raspberry, and pineapple fillings
- Fresh strawberries
- Cream cheese icing
- Chocolate whipped cream
What icing and finish options are available?
In addition to buttercream and whipped cream, we offer:
- Cream cheese icing
- Chocolate whipped cream
- White fondant
- Ivory fondant
- Chocolate ganache
- White chocolate ganache
These are great for clean, elegant designs, especially for wedding and special event cakes.
Do you make gender reveal cakes or themed cakes?
Absolutely. Our cake decorators can create gender reveal cakes, cartoon and character themes, sports cakes, floral designs, and more. Just bring us your idea, and we’ll make it happen.
Do you make cupcake cakes or platters?
Yes, we offer cupcake platters and pull-apart cupcake cakes. These are fun, easy-to-serve options that work well for birthdays, school events, and casual celebrations.
Can I order a personalized birthday cake?
Yes, personalized birthday cakes are one of our most requested items. From simple sheet cakes to custom-decorated layer or tiered cakes, we’ll design a cake that fits the celebration perfectly.